Erdos Ko Rado Theorem
Let $\mathcal{F}$ be a family of $ k $-element subsets of $ \{ 1,2,\dots,n \} $ such that every two sets in $\mathcal{F} $ intersect in at least one element. Then show that $ | \mathcal{F} | \leq \binom{n-1}{k-1}$
Claim : Let $ X $ be any permutation of $ \{ 1,2 \dots, n \} $ on a circle. Consider all the intervals of the length $k$. Then at most $k$ such intervals belongs to $ \mathcal{F} $
Proof : Consider all the intervals $ \in \mathcal{F} $ ( in clockwise order ), we color the last element of the interval blue, and the element just before its first term red.
The marked set represents the interval |
Now we show that no element has both the colors.
Suppose on the contrary, $ \exists $ an element which is both colored blue as well as red, then the two intervals defined by this element are disjoint, which gives us a contradiction.
Now consider the element which is colored blue. Then, in the next $ n - 2k $ elements, none of them can be colored red, because or else, the two intervals would be disjoint.
The blue points are obtained from the red points by moving $k$ units in clockwise direction. So as $ \exists $ an interval of length $ n -2k $, with no red points $ \Rightarrow \exists $ an interval of length $ n - 2k $, with no blue points.
Now, rotate this interval of length $ n - 2k $ until the first time its first element is following a blue point, then this interval of $ n-2k $ has no blue points as well as no red points. So the remaining $ 2k $ points contains all the red and blue points, and as each element has only one color, we get there are at most $k$ red points and $k$ blue points. Hence there are at most $k$ such intervals, which completes our claim.
Now we are going to use another very fundamental strategy in combinatorics problem, which is double counting.
Let us count the number of tuples
$ T = \{ (A, \sigma ) | A \in \mathcal{F} \mbox{ and } \sigma \mbox{ be a cyclic permutation of }\{1,2,\dots,n \} \mbox{ which contains } A \} $
First let us fix $A$, then there are $ k!(n-k)! $ permutations of $ \{ 1,2,\dots,n\} $ on a circle such that it contains $A$.
$ \Rightarrow | T | = | \mathcal{F} | k!(n-k)! $
Now let us fix $ \sigma $, then by our claim $ \exists $ at most $ k $ intervals $\in \mathcal{F} $.
$\Rightarrow |T| \leq (n-1)! k$
$ \therefore | \mathcal{F} | k!(n-k)! \leq (n-1)! k $
$ \boxed{ \Rightarrow | \mathcal{F} | \leq \binom{n-1}{k-1} } $
Hence, proved.
Comments
Post a Comment